On February 10, 2015, the Wall Street Journal published an article entitled “Everything Is Awesome! Why You Can’t Tell Employees They’re Doing a Bad Job” extolling the virtues of praising employees’ strengths and scaling back on criticism. Although this may be good for employees’ confidence levels, it is bad for companies when they have to defend a discrimination lawsuit or oppose a bid for unemployment benefits.For example, in September 2011, a New York woman sued in federal court claiming that her employer “mommy-tracked” her by attempting to demote her, refusing to promote her, and cutting her bonus after she took maternity leave, despite repeatedly earning positive performance ratings during her career with the company. The company argued that she was lawfully terminated because her reviews were done by an “easy grader” and she was not meeting the company’s other metrics. In January 2015, the federal judge overseeing the case stated that the case looked strong enough to go to trial due in part to the questions of fact presented by the positive performance reviews.
Performance reviews are valuable tools for employers. While they may be used to boost an employee’s self-esteem and confidence, employers should carefully train their supervisors and manager to give honest feedback and critiques when necessary. Problems should not be sugar-coated; the issue, the steps to correct the issue, and the consequences for failing to correct the issue need to be included in evaluations and reviews. These honest assessments on an employee’s performance are essential to being able to discipline and terminate an employee if that becomes necessary, as well as defending the company from a lawsuit or claim for unemployment compensation.
In April 2024, the Department of Labor announced a final rule, entitled Defining and Delimiting the…
The recent Tax Court case Estate of Anne Milner Fields v. Commissioner underscores the risks…
The recent election of Donald Trump as president signals potential changes to the U.S. tax…
Each year, Super Lawyers surveys the State of Wisconsin’s 15,000 attorneys and judges, seeking the State’s top…
O’Neil Cannon has been recognized regionally in the 2025 edition of Best Law Firms®, ranked…
Construction lien waivers are an indispensable part of the traditional construction payment process, allowing parties…